Pursuing Redemption
Welcome home where healing and restoration is celebrated in stories from those who have walked through fire and come out on the other side. Welcome to the Pursing Redemption podcast with Heather Shore. #innerhealing #deliverance #jesus #holyspirit #god
Pursuing Redemption
When Church Teachings Cause Harm: Sheila Wray Gregoire on Marriage, Submission & Abuse
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
What happens when the teachings meant to strengthen Christian marriages actually contribute to shame, inequality, and even abuse?
This episode was a joy to record and a personal one for me.
I sit down with bestselling author, speaker, and researcher @sheilagregoire of the Bare Marriage Podcast and author of The Great Sex Rescue, to challenge some of the deeply rooted beliefs surrounding marriage, sex, submission, and gender roles within evangelical Christianity.
Sheila shares her personal faith journey and what led her to question popular Christian marriage teachings. Together, we explore how the misuse of Scripture, distorted definitions of submission, and messages promoted through Christian books and church culture can create unhealthy power dynamics, silence women, and perpetuate cycles of harm.
At the heart of this conversation is an important question: Are we teaching people to follow Jesus, or are we defending religious traditions that sometimes hurt the very people we're called to love?
This episode is an invitation to rethink what we've been taught, recognize harmful patterns, and rediscover a faith rooted in truth, mutual respect, freedom, and the redemptive love of Jesus.
Because pursuing redemption sometimes means having the courage to question what we've always believed.
Follow along at Instagram @restoringministriesok or Facebook @restoringministriesok. To learn more, check out heathervshore.com.
Everybody goes away.
SPEAKER_00Welcome home, where healing and restoration are celebrated in stories from those who have walked through fire and come out the other side. Welcome to the Pursuing Redemption Podcast with Heather Shore.
SPEAKER_02Well, Sheila, thank you so much for coming on the Pursuing Redemption Show. We're super excited to have you. Yeah, thanks for having me. Yay. We would love you to tell us a little bit of your journey of coming to know Jesus.
SPEAKER_01Well, I have always known Jesus. Like I grew up where my mom took me to church, really taught me about Jesus. She was a single mom. And so I was lonely as a kid. Like I'm Gen X, right? So we didn't have the internet. And so on Sunday afternoons, there was nothing to do except watch TV, and there was never anything good on TV. So I spent a lot of my time quite lonely, only child with single mom. And I think maybe because of that, I really had a close relationship with Jesus even as a kid. Like I take walks with him and talk to him. And he really was my best friend. And that continued throughout my life. I I really wanted to serve Jesus. I I really loved Jesus. I did a lot of missions trips as a teenager and into my young adulthood. You know, I wanted to build my life around him. And so um, yeah, some of the things that have happened more recently, where I've seen how a lot of the people who claim Jesus don't act like it have been really difficult to process because he's always been such an important part of my life.
SPEAKER_02I I love that. So, what part of your formative years really shaped the theology that we see today?
SPEAKER_01I think perhaps because I was the child of a single mother, I saw how much my mom had to work. Yeah. I saw how strong she was. I saw some pretty bad relationships that she got into and then got out of because she wasn't willing, you know, to put me through that or herself through that. And she had to learn the hard way that she was worth it, you know? Um, and so I I grew up seeing that life could be hard for women. Um and I just always felt like that wasn't of God, like there was a better way. And yeah, and so I'm hoping that that I'm trying to help people find that.
SPEAKER_02That's amazing. So then what I guess you're raised by a single mom. I guess that moves you towards this journey of marriage and and meeting your husband and everything. So what really I guess propelled you towards tackling a very, a very important topic in the church, which is building marriage and really changing lives, and and what moved you that direction?
SPEAKER_01It really wasn't, it wasn't intentional. Like I like to say, nobody grows up thinking, you know what I really want to do is is become the Christian sex lady or or talk about sex all the time. Um and I had written a couple of small books in the early 2000s. I was staying home with my kids. I had a couple of post grad degrees, but my husband was a physician, still is, um, was very busy. And so I was home with the kids and I was looking for something to do. So I was writing magazine articles, I wrote some small books, and then in 2008, I started blogging because everybody was blogging in 2008. Um and I became a mommy blogger, and I was talking about housework and organizing and parenting and all of that. And I found that the more I talked about sex, the more my traffic grew. And so I would write an occasional article about sex and it would grow go really big. And so I kind of leaned into that. And I had a couple of big books published in the 2010s on sex in the evangelical world. And uh yeah, and it it was just, it was all an accident. It wasn't anything planned.
SPEAKER_02That's awesome. And so you're really just bringing like practical knowledge and just your life experience to the whole discussion.
SPEAKER_01Well, yes, and and I would say, and I would say research, because one of the things that we've always done as part of our team is is um anything we write, we back it up with peer-reviewed research. So even in those early days when I was writing before we started doing our own research, I, you know, I was looking at the literature and I was finding out best practices and best evidence-based advice. So yeah.
SPEAKER_02That's great. I mean, you have to have evidence to support it for sure. And so that really takes us to your book of the great sex rescue, which is a wonderful, wonderful book of unpacking some of the lies that we've all believed. I think what really surprised you the most during all the research that you guys did of, you know, what's going on in Christian environments, what's going on in Christian marriages in general, and then how that's impacting really society.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So um, so I had been writing about sex uh in the 2010s. And then in 2019, we took a major turn in the road um to what we do as a team because I had I sat down and I read Love and Respect, and which is the best-selling book by Emerson Eggerich. It's it's uh the most used marriage study in North American churches, or at least it used to be. I don't know if it still is. I hope it's not. Um and up until then, I hadn't read a lot of other evangelical books because I was being really naive. I just figured, I love Jesus, they love Jesus. We're all saying basically the same thing, just in different ways. And when I read Love and Respect, I realized, oh my gosh, we are so not saying the same thing. Because that book was so centered around men's experience and it completely ignored women's. Um, you know, saying that he needs sexual release and you don't, and if he doesn't get sexual release, he'll come under satanic attack. And so you need to minister to your to her husband to your husband sexually, and that's okay because it takes so little time. And it was like it was bizarre. Um, and there's so much more bizarre things about that book. And and so, you know, we thought, well, we we need to do something about this because people don't seem to be listening when we say this is wrong advice. And we didn't want to just have an argument, um, you know, a theological argument about is this biblical or is it not? Because so many people have been doing that, and it it rarely changes minds. So we thought, we'll just look at data. And we did um our first study that we did, we've done four since, I think. Okay. Um, but that was our first big one. It was 22,000 women for for the Great Sex Rescue. And it was a very long survey. So if anyone's listening who did it, thank you very much. I know that was a big investment of your time. Um, but you know, we were looking at sexual satisfaction, marital satisfaction, but then we were also looking at a whole bunch of different beliefs that are common in evangelicalism and seeing if people had ever taught it, if if they had believed it, if they had been taught it, and how that correlated with marital and sexual satisfaction. Okay. And um, you know, on our team, so there's three authors on the book. There's my daughter Rebecca, who did a lot of the writing and a lot in the survey design. Um, there's me who did a lot of the writing, but I also analyzed all the evangelical books that we were critiquing. And then there's Joanna who did all the stats. And I think what surprised me most um was just how bad the advice is in our bestsellers. Like, not a single one of our best-selling resources in evangelicalism even mentioned the word consent. Like, how can you not mention the word consent if you're writing about sex? And the vast majority of them talked about women's obligation to have sex without even mentioning that sex is supposed to feel good for women too. Yeah. So, you know, we have this 47-point orgasm gap and uh um in the church, and that actually is something that surprised me. I thought it was gonna be higher. Um, but where 95% of men almost always were always reach orgasmed compared to just 48% of women. And there's a lot of women who and and we have twice the rate of sexual pain disorders in evangelicalism than in the general population. You know, so there's a lot of women who aren't getting anything out of sex where sometimes it's even hurting or sometimes they're even feeling used. Yeah. And the main message in evangelical bestsellers is you just need to do it more. And I I found that very sobering.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And that really does lead to other issues. I know that you guys tackle a multitude of topics, which I think is great and everything, but how do you find because I think it's misused, and I know it's been misused against me personally, but how do you find the misuse of the word submission causing more marital issues and really teaching about what it is?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think the way that submission is taught is largely that the way that a woman serves Jesus is by following her husband. So the way that you follow Jesus is to follow your husband. You're not that that that is essentially putting your husband in the role of Jesus in your life because following your husband is not following Jesus. Your husband is not Jesus, and it's very clear scripturally that we are supposed to be following Jesus, whether we are male or female. And when you read Ephesians 5.21, that we are to submit to one another, and then you read Ephesians 5.22, which continues in the same thought, it's not a separate thought. In English Bibles, there's often a section break there with a with a title like household codes or marriage codes or whatever. Um so in English it says wives submit to your husbands, but in Greek it just says wives to your husbands. There's no verb because it's the the meaning is inferred from the previous verse. So women submit to their husbands in the same way that all believers submit to one another. So this is not a submission that is about authority or hierarchy. This is about just being humble and deferring to one another and serving one another, as Jesus talks about in Matthew 20, how it's the Gentiles that worry about power and authority, and it isn't supposed to be that way with us. Um, and and you think about Philippians 2, where Paul wrote, Paul writes that we're to have the mind of Christ, right? Who didn't consider equality with God, something to be grasped, but made himself a servant. And that's what it's talking about is that we're supposed to serve, you know, we're all supposed to be serving one another. Wives, yeah, to your husbands, but then Paul spends much greater time talking about what submission looks like for men, how they're supposed to love their wives as Christ loved the church and gave herself up. And um, so he doesn't take that much time addressing women because women were already doing it. He takes a much longer time addressing men. And yet in the church, we spend so much time telling women that they are supposed to let their husbands make the final decision. And there's nothing in that passage that talks about the final decision. There's nothing in that passage that talks about authority, but people read it in there. You know, the only place in scripture in the New Testament where decisions in marriage are actually talked about is in 1 Corinthians 7. And there it's by mutual consent, like decision making is mutual. Um, and we've measured this for our book, The Marriage You Want, where when couples get married, believing that he gets the final decision, um, those marriages are far more likely to end in divorce. They're not as happy. We see far higher uh markers of emotional immaturity. Um, you know, it's very correlated with emotional immaturity, correlated with really bad conflict resolution skills. Like these are not good marriages. This this really bears bad fruit. But when couples serve each other while following after Jesus together, we see really good fruit. And so I I think I think what's happened is we've used the word submission to tell women that you need to be under the authority of your husband when the Bible doesn't say that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's so true. I guess then, too, when you look at some of the books that have been pushed out there, like you mentioned love and respect, do you feel like that is something that they're using to sort of gain control of people? Meaning that like when you look at abusive marriages, right, it's all about power and control. And then you look at some denominations and they push this agenda pretty pretty heavily within the Christian church. Why do you think this narrative is being pushed? Because at the end of the day, there's higher rates of abuse, and I've seen the correlating data for that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I think um that in far too many corners, well, okay. Here's what I would say: some people serve Christ and follow Christ because they truly want to bring love into the world, they love God, they want to see God's love into the world. And some people uh serve Christ and claim the name of Christ because they want the power that comes with that. And these two groups of people are reading the same Bible, they are attending the same churches, they are singing the same songs, and sometimes they're even sharing the same pew or the same bed. But Christ doesn't mean the same thing to both of them. And I think there's a lot of women who genuinely love God and are trying to serve Jesus, and they're being told that the way that you serve Jesus is you give up your autonomy and um you let other people walk all over you, and you become a doormat and you put up with abuse and you put up with terrible things because God will reward you in your suffering. And a lot of men are pushing this because it gives them a place to be powerful, you know. If you think about how much society has changed over the last few decades, men no longer get a free ride in the same way that they used to. You know, they there's nowhere else in society where a man can claim that he has authority over a woman and still be the good guy.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_01If he were to do that anywhere other than the church, he would be reprimanded, he would be, you know, whatever. Now, I'm not talking about with your buddies, but I'm talking about officially. Like you think about the workplace, schools, um, government agencies, whatever. Like you're not allowed to say that women have to be under men. But in church, you can do it and you're applauded for it. And so I think a lot of men are attracted to church today because it lets them be an authority and it lets them be important in a way that they can't be in society anymore. Because now, in order to be important and to have authority, you have to actually have some merit. You have to do something that is worth it. But in church, it's just handed to you. Just because you're a guy, you get to be in authority over the the women in your life. Um and so I think a lot of people are gravitating towards books which spread those messages and to churches that spread those messages because it seems it it's very enticing to them. And they're not being enticed by Jesus, they're being enticed by power. They're actually rejecting Jesus and doing so.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02So for you and your own personal marriage, how did you guys come to an understanding of like, hey, we're gonna live this out, you know, where it's a partnership?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, we've always been that way. Like, there's been a few times, like early, early, early in our marriage where we were in complementarian spaces, and um, you know, Keith was thinking, like, what does this look like? Because what he was really afraid of is I don't want to be, I don't, like, if God wants me to take leadership, I don't want to not take leadership and become passive. Like I, you know, I want, I want to be, take initiative. Um, and so he would struggle with what that looks like. But ultimately, we just decided that looked like us both taking initiative together, you know, and that's kind of how we've always been. Like I like to say we've been married 35 years and we've never had to have him make the final decision because we just we just figured out and and we've had some pretty big things to decide on, you know, like big moves, career changes. We had a a a very ill child um where we had to make decisions about whether to put him on a heart transplant list or not, like huge, huge, huge things. And we initially disagreed on and um had to work through like huge things to work through, but we worked through them, you know? Um and this idea that well, obviously you're gonna need someone to make the final decision because there's some things you just can't agree on. No, there's not. Like, if there's not, if you can't agree, that's a that's a red flag that there's something wrong with your marriage. And you should probably be getting help for that. Yeah. It doesn't mean, oh, well, this is the time where God just wants him to overrule her. Like, that's not that's not what it what marriage should look like. Sure.
SPEAKER_02And those times where you run into that, well, say there's a red flag in your marriage. What do you guys recommend out to your audience? I'm just more curious than anything.
SPEAKER_01Um, you know, there's there's uh I've asked, I've asked other people this too. We for our book, The Marriage You Want, you know, we were saying, like, how do you guys make decisions? And and people have said, like, like, if sometimes something is just more important to one of us. So we might not initially agree, but for someone, it's like this serious. So we'll see, so we'll say, okay, on a scale of one to ten, how important is this to you? And one person has it at a two, and one person has it at an eight. Well, then the eight gets to make the decision because it doesn't really matter to the two, right? So you may not agree, but it's like it doesn't really matter. Or in some cases, one of you is just way more knowledgeable about this, or it's gonna affect one of you a lot more. Like which stove we're gonna buy. I'm gonna decide that because I'm the one who cooks, you know. Um, if it's which which washing machine, he's gonna decide that because he's the one who does the laundry. Like, like it's it's who it affects, right? Um uh so it's not always that we have to sit down and think exactly the same way. Sometimes it's like, you know what, this really matters to you, so you run with it.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_01Like that's that's perfectly okay. Um, and then if it's something bigger, like, do we move to a different city? Do we quit our job? Do we, you know, what do we do about kids or something? You you you sit down or you pray about it. You take the time that it needs. You think about, you think about, okay, why do I want to move to another city? What is it that I'm getting out of it? And is there another way that I can get that same, those same benefits, but staying here? Or is there another way? Like, like, is it about moving to another city or is it about something else? I need a new group of friends. I'm excited about this job opportunity. Well, is there something similar we could take here? So, you know, looking beyond the surface and realizing that it's not really about whether or not we agree we should move to another city, it's we're getting some need, we we have some needs that aren't being met right now. What are other ways we can meet them? And if we start brainstorming, maybe we'll see there's a third option we haven't even considered. You know, so we've done that a lot too.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. That's really good. And this is a total side question. These next two questions are a little bit more side questions, opinions, I should say. Have you watched The Pastor's Wife on Netflix? Yes. You have. I would love to know your thoughts on that because I just my heart is broken because I feel like she just didn't get the help she needed.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so um, for those of you who don't know that, yeah, the Netflix series Death of a Pastor's Wife covers the tragic story of Micah Miller, um, who was basically looks like she was basically groomed by her pastor from the time she was a teenager. And when she was 20, the supposed affair started, although we all know that that is not the correct term, because when a pastor is having sex with a congregant, especially one who is like 15 or 17 years younger, that is clergy sex abuse. Um, and the marriages eventually broke up and they married, but that marriage was full of sexual abuse. And she eventually tried to escape and she supposedly committed suicide. I think that's still a little bit up for debate. Um her demise is not is not clear. Um but what the what the documentary was really looking at was how awful his behavior was. And it was clear that it was awful because he was giving terrible sermons about how women had to meet their husbands' every sexual need, or the husband would just be in agony, and he would do, you know, he would have no choice but to sin. Um, and don't you know that God created the wife to give their husband sex, you know, and and it just seemed like he was constantly talking about this and constantly talking about how women needed to submit. And at the same time as as the marriage was obviously in trouble. And it turns out behind the scenes, he was also forcing her to take testosterone to keep up to a sex drive. He was, you know, basically raping her four or five times a day. Like it was it was truly despicable. But this this was. Not difficult for congregants to see. And I think what surprised me is that so many people stayed. You know, even after she filed for divorce, even after she died, people were still giving this man standing ovations. And even her friends who were in the documentary who aren't going to the church anymore, they say things like what JP taught was obviously biblical, but he took it too far. And it's like, no, it wasn't biblical at all. Like even her friends still don't see through the fog that what he was teaching was not biblical. And I think that's that's what made me really sad.
SPEAKER_02It's almost to the point where it feels like they're a little bit brainwashed.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. But I think we need to start taking some responsibility for that because this idea, you know, we're we're we need to know our Bible. We don't know our Bible.
SPEAKER_02That's part of it.
SPEAKER_01No, we don't know our Bible, and and we have to start learning to listen to our gut to take some agency here. And if a pastor is preaching terrible things about sex, it's okay to stand up and walk out. Yes. You know, it's okay to stop going to that church. We need to normalize walking out in the middle of sermons. I think so many churches would be better if people just walked out in the middle of sermons. Um, we need to normalize like leaving places that are toxic. Uh, because when we stay in toxic churches or in churches that are teaching that men are over women, even if you were in a good place, there's people that aren't in a good place. And by going there, by giving your time, by volunteering, you're creating a church situation where women can be abused. Like there wouldn't have been a Micah Miller being abused if there were not people in the pews at that church.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. Yeah. I think if we would just pull our money too, I think that would make a big difference. Absolutely. Yeah. That's what they're funded on. Okay, so for the the next one, why do you think, and again, this is just an opinion, some of the people online that are really pushing the narrative of complementarism, like across the board, and and one of those particular people is Alisa Childers. And I find some of that interesting, especially because she started out so great with like going after apologetics and like really, I mean, I loved her at the beginning, and now it's just turned into this. I don't even know what it is anymore. But why do you think they come after people like you?
SPEAKER_01Is it just because we're kind of interesting narrative? Because they didn't for years. Like um when the Great Sex Rescue was out, we actually thought there'd be more pushback, but there wasn't because what we were primarily going after was the messages that women owe men sex, and no matter what, um, and it's honestly pretty hard to defend that. Like it's it's it's actually pretty hard to defend that sex should just be about a guy. Um, it's pretty hard to defend the orgasm gap. And every now and then somebody would try to come after me. Like I remember Denny Burke, um, who was with the Council for Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, criticized the Great Sex Rescue because uh we took a selfish approach to sex by looking at female orgasm instead of looking at reproduction, and it was just like it just got so land-based, because like, buddy, you can have both. Like, you know, he's like, we got the male orgasm in reproduction, so why can't we have the female? And it's to the thought that it was selfish to look for a female orgasm, but not to go for male orgasm was just really an interesting take. Um, so and he got he got pretty slammed down hard. And so people haven't tended to go after me for sex. But when our latest book was out, The Marriage You Want, about a year and a half ago, we really did look at the data there for what happens when um people follow complementarianism. So when they do put the husband in authority over their wife. And we shared a lot of data from our surveys. And I think that's when people started going after us because now we're really threatening their power base. Because, yeah, you know, like we had a lot, we have a lot of complementarians who agree with what we say about sex. There's a lot of complementarians who, yeah, we might believe that men are in authority, but we do believe that that sex should be for both men and women. And yeah, you know, um, but once we started looking at the data, which clearly shows that egalitarian marriages do better, um, it got people very nervous. And I I think I've been on people's radar for years, but they they thought, well, if we don't attack her, then she'll just go away. Like it won't, she won't get big. But as I've been getting bigger, people have seen me, I think, as more of a threat. And and so I think that's why Alyssa came after us with some really spurious and kind of stupid criticisms. But yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. It's just been very interesting.
SPEAKER_01Or not well thought out, anyway. I should say not well thought out. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. But I figured it was probably because it's impacting some sort of revenue bottom line, to be super honest for a lot of these people. And that's why they come after those that are going after their narrative. They could potentially take away some of the revenue.
SPEAKER_01And I think you're right. Like I think there were a lot of people who were more reasonable a couple of years ago. But as I'm speaking as a Canadian, so I'm kind of looking into what's happening in America from outside of America. And I mean, up here, we're all kind of just shaking our heads because everything is getting very polarized in the US, it seems. Um, and I think as things have gotten more polarized, people who have chosen to be more on the political right, on the Christian nationalism side, it's like you can't acknowledge that the other side has anything correct.
SPEAKER_02Um, it's ridiculous.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So it's like we have to shut down the other side completely. And so while I think a lot of people would have been more open to just, yeah, you know, marriage is probably better when we decide together. Uh, now they can't acknowledge that. And interestingly, in in Alyssa Childers' uh critiques of our work, she actually said that she and her husband make decisions together. And it's like, well, honey, then what are you upset about? Like, but it so it's not even it's like they just can't give ground to the idea that men are in authority over women because that threatens too much of what they hold dear. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's that's the craziness that's going on down here. It's been it's been amazing to see. So I guess from our standpoint, our podcast is focused a lot on healing and everything. Have you had any healing testimonies come through as a result of your writing?
SPEAKER_01You know, one of the things I was very surprised at, we were all very surprised at, was how many divorced people read The Great Sex Rescue. So we deliberately um against divorced people. So yeah, we we recruited a lot of um survey takers from some some uh divorce groups, so of evangelicals who had gone through divorce. Because one of our concerns about previous um research in marriage is that we were only surveying married people, and so we were missing what happened. Like if you think about it, if we're if we believe that this advice is toxic, we need to talk to the people for whom it, you know, marriages ended in divorce. If we're only looking at people who are still in intact marriages, we've got something called a survivorship bias. So we might be missing out on some of the real stories. So um, you know, if if the the evangelical divorce rate is between 30 and 35%, so we were hoping for that. We only got 16% divorce, so it was, you know, but still 16% is way, way higher than than other surveys that we've gotten. And we certainly had statistically significant results. Um so we had a lot of divorced people take the survey. And I think some of my favorite emails that I've gotten are from women who said, you know, I left my marriage five years ago and I read your book, and for the first time I understand that God wasn't okay with what happened to me. Because, you know, they felt like God was the one telling them you have to submit to abuse, basically, or you have to give your body to him. You're not allowed to deprive, and even if he's being disgusting, and even if he's dehumanizing you, and even if he's objectifying you, God is pleased with what is happening because you're walking in obedience. And you know, for them to see that God was never pleased with them being used um was really healing. And I think my favorite stories are I mean, yes, it's great to hear about marriages that get restored or people that finally have a path to intimacy in their marriage, and that's wonderful. But I think the ones that I really enjoy seeing are I I found Jesus because of this. Like I was walking away from Jesus because I have always been taught that the only way to follow Jesus is this, you know, very umbrella authority focused way. And to see that Jesus actually cares about women means that I don't have to walk away. And and that's what I love. That's what I just love. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Oh, that's amazing. Can you tell us what you're working on next?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so in in March, um, yeah, in March, our next book is out. It's called Fawn, How a Trauma Response Became Biblical Womanhood, and How Women Can Reclaim Their Agency. And so, you know, we started running out about sex, and then we we took a more of a bird's eye view and we wrote about marriage, and now we're taking an even greater bird's eye view, and we're looking at at biblical womanhood and women as a whole. And if you look at the advice that's given to women in evangelical circles, it basically is the fawn trauma response. It's shrink, be silent, make yourself super agreeable, flatter, appease, you know, don't expect anything, take the blame. These are all things that you do when you fawn. And fawning is a trauma response where you try to keep yourself safe by making yourself appealing to the threat. And they're teaching women to make ourselves appealing to the people who are more powerful than us. And and people fawn when they're in under constant threat of abuse. So the classic fawners are children who grow up in abusive families where you're never sure when abuse is coming. And so you teach yourself to monitor the emotions of everyone around you, to try to figure out how everyone's feeling, you know, to make yourself small, to not be noticed so that you you aren't a target. But the other place fawning can occur is when there's just a basic power imbalance. When there's a real power imbalance and you're vulnerable, people automatically fawn. That's just that's just what we do. And it's amazing how in evangelical circles, they have taken that instinctual response to a power differential and given it God language to make it sound like this is what God ordained for women to be like for all time. When what Jesus really ordained was to get rid of the power differential.
SPEAKER_02That is right. Wow. Oh my gosh, I'm excited about that one. I will go out and buy a copy for sure. And you can pre-order it now. Yeah. Yeah, you can pre-order it now. Oh, yay. Yes. Okay.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02On Amazon?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, anywhere. It's just called Fawn. Yeah. By Sheila Gregoire. Yes. That's amazing.
SPEAKER_02Oh, Sheila, I'm excited. I'm gonna go pre-order today. If you could tell somebody to pursue redemption and chase after Jesus, what would you say?
SPEAKER_01Um I think that we have to remember that Jesus may not look like what we've been told Jesus looks like in church. And I think the reason that Jesus tells us to approach him like a little child is that we often extinctively get what God is like when we're kids, right? God loves you, God wants to hug you, God wants to embrace you, God wants to make things nice for you. God, God wants you to flourish. And then as we get older, we get all of these messages about how it's not that God loves you, it's that, well, you know I love you, but you could be trying a little harder, you could be a little more thankful. You're really lacking on self-discipline. And we see God kind of like as an angry magazine cover pointing out all of your flaws. Um and I think a lot of us need to go back to what we were as a child and who we knew God as then, instinctively, and how we would go to God for comfort and we would go to God for assurance that everything is right with the world. Um and if you're in a place where you can't see God like that, then my encouragement would be to get into a different space because there really are healthy churches, there really are. Um they just may not look like what you're in now. And I think there's a great uh sorting or sifting going on, um where it's becoming more and more clear who wants to see the kingdom of God on earth as it is in heaven and who wants the kingdom of man. Um and often, as I said, we use the same Bible and the same words, but we're not meaning the same thing. And so seek out like-minded people. It might be hard to find, you know, it might not be obvious, but seek out like-minded people because we need that fellowship. We need to know we're not alone. And uh yeah, there's something very beautiful in that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there is. Oh my gosh, this has been amazing! Thank you so much for coming on today. I know the listeners get so much out of it. Um any final words that you might have for people?
SPEAKER_01Um yeah, I just, you know, um we like to say that we're just trying to change the conversation. And so if if things just haven't made sense to you, then I would just encourage you to pick up our books. Like check out The Great Sex Rescue. Um, check out our book, She Deserves Better if you're recovering from purity culture. Uh, and and maybe it'll give you Yeah, maybe it'll give you a different glimpse of who Jesus is, because that is our goal. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, thank you so much.
SPEAKER_01Thank you.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Shawn Ryan Show
Shawn Ryan